The Primary Difference Between Liberals and Conservatives, Part II

So who’s correct? Which view of humanity best describes the way we actually are? Most of you won’t believe it at first, but for the most part the reality is that people are basically evil (but exceedingly valuable). This is why Liberalism doesn’t work. It relies on an erroneous foundation that believes people are intrinsically good (but not very valuable). As a result, it gets wrong nearly all resulting responses.

Don’t believe people are evil? Consider the natural state of children. They don’t need to be taught to be dishonest, selfish, disobedient, or to hit other children. Those things come naturally to children.

What about adults? No one trains us to be lazy, lustful, gluttonous, angry, proud, power hungry, irresponsible or ungrateful—and yet we are all of those things. These things need to be trained out of both young and old, and closely guarded against if they are to be avoided at all. And, when we are caught in some transgression, is our first response to stand up, take responsibility and make amends for our act? Generally not. Our first impulse is to lie, cover up, and try to weasel a way out of it.

And it doesn’t work to claim that people are basically good, but that we are corrupted by “society.” How could society be a bad influence if it is nothing more than a collection of people, all of whom are intrinsically good?

We do have a few basic impulses that are good, like the love of parents and children for each other. But the majority of good values and behaviors come from outside ourselves, eventually tracing back to God’s commandments.

Put simply, badness is the human condition. The Bible puts it like this: “The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it? (Jeremiah 17:9)”

We have a natural gravity toward depravity. The function of government must therefore be to restrain our natural appetites, not facilitate them. The answer to crime isn’t to just legalize everything. The purpose of government must be to restrain evil—our evil. To diagnose our condition otherwise is to condemn our resulting actions to failure.